Sunday, June 21, 2015

I See It, but I'm Not Quite Sure What It Is

Below is my abstract for Queer Manuscripts Roundtable at the 2016 New Chaucer Society conference:

I See It, but I'm Not Quite Sure What It Is,
or The Discomfort with Cleanness as a Naked Text

Cotton Nero A.x holds two of the most beautifully crafted poems in Middle English—Pearl and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight—which, although challenging in their fusion of religious and courtly values, seem intelligible compared to their abject, ugly sibling, Cleanness. We modern readers generally do not like Cleanness—it reads like a Westboro Baptist preacher’s call to join a wrathful God in hating faggots. But is that what Cleanness says, or is that what we expect Cleanness to say? I propose that by stripping Cleanness down to the flesh of its manuscript, eliminating its modern editorial features, we reveal a much more ambiguous textual body, the form of which seduces us with the pretense of an unspeakable secret even as it ultimately resists a singular reading.

Cleanness, in the flesh, reveals a structured body that does not quite correspond to its subject matter. Modern editors, attempting to make the text a bit straighter, have ignored the manuscript’s awkward textual divisions and have inserted notes to explain away ambiguities. Just as this queer text relates stories of bodies touching bodies (including the body of God), we must consider our carnal inter(t)action with the queer manuscript. We must ask what it means for one to desire amorous intimacy with an embodied, not-quite-male Jesus, as we explore this not-quite-readable poem. Only by learning to respect the text’s resistance to our appropriative desire for comprehension can we begin to recognize the text’s challenging polysemy that invites comparisons with its sister poems.

Thursday, June 11, 2015

Puking Out Pearls

Below is my abstract for the 2015 BABEL Working Group conference:

Lady Gaga is fabulous. She came out on the scene with a fabulous single and a fabulous album about being fabulous, and we were all starstruck; we were also seduced by her illegibility. We wanted her to be a man, dressed as a woman. We wanted evidence of a penis behind the layers of glitter, makeup, wigs, and bubbles. Gaga performed femininity in a way that recalled and surpassed drag queens, and we were, ironically, confused at her female body—What could it mean for a woman to play at being a woman? Starting from this illegibility, Gaga carefully cultivated a persona that not only performed the fabulosity she articulated in her music, but also exposed the mechanisms of legibility in what Benjamin has called the age of mechanical reproduction—Gaga became intertextual with herself, and we began to feel like we understood her without fully understanding her.
            Terence Koh is fabulous. When the artist was asked to explain his fabulous appearance, he responded, “That is my nature. Perhaps we shouldn’t interview with what happens most naturally.” Koh’s fabulosity is natural, and it is artificial; it is truth, but, in his art, truth is deception and self-deception: “I get scared and don’t want to know the truth…. I tink [sic] this way there could be world peace. And really people would just be more happy.” Koh has cultivated a look, a phonetic/homonymic writing style, a form of artwork featuring “layered insincerity,” and the slopes of his performed self are always a bit slippery—his natural artifice (or artificial nature) blurs boundaries between legibility and illegibility. Sometimes not asking questions reveals the most answers. Maybe, Koh teaches us, the essence is not as important as the meaningfulness of the surface.[1]
            Pearls are fabulous. Terence and Gaga collaborated on a fabulous video and a fabulous performance featuring fabulous pearls—88 pearls to be in/exact (which might mean something)—and these fabulous pearls might also remind us of many fabulous people’s disease and death.[2]
            Un/like Gaga and Terence, the Pearl-maiden is fabulous. She lives in a jewel-encrusted world of numeric complexity (which also might mean something). She reminds us of daughters and statues, idolatry and death. She reminds us of the kingdom of heaven and wealth, whores and lambs. Can we ingest her, or does she resist consumption? All we know, by the end of the poem, is that we have never seen anyone more fabulous.
*     *     *
Frustrated and confused at my writing style, my professor recently wrote to me: “[Your] essay sometimes feels merely clever rather than substantial. It is charming, but it entails too much rhetorical performance, too little sustained analysis.” Exploring the meaningful absurdity of Lady Gaga’s and Terence Koh’s fabulous resistances to legibility, I would like to consider what might be gained from reading the maiden in Pearl through the lens of clever and charming rhetorical performance and what might be lost if we care too deeply about traditions of  “substantial… sustained analysis.” My talk will be fabulous.



[1] “Down the Bunny Hole,” interview by Kathy Grayson <http://terencekoh.com/hole/down-the-bunny-hole>
[2] Lady Gaga and Terence Koh collaborated for the American Foundation for AIDS Research. After sipping from a teacup on top of a piano, Lady Gaga spits out a mouthful of pearls, which Koh describes as “puking out beautiful things.” <http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/lady-gaga-salutes-elton-john-with-special-set-at-all-star-amfar-gala-20100211>

Thursday, September 25, 2014

Beautiful Filth

Below is my abstract for the 2015 Medieval Congress at Kalamazoo:

Beautiful Filth: Cleanness’s Sensually Appealing Sins and the
Dirtiness of the Incarnation

Cleanness begins with a seemingly straightforward distinction—clean things are beautiful and filthy things are not.  If we could trust the poet’s logic, we would safely be able to assume that an object must be clean if it appeals to our senses through its “fayre formez.”  The poem’s first biblical allusion, the parable of the wedding feast, seems to continue this argument by proposing that ugly things do not have a place in the kingdom of heaven, but those that are “frely and fresch fonde” and “fetyse of a fayr forme” are acceptable in God’s sight. The poem’s succeeding exempla each present to the reader sensually enticing descriptions that stand out from the text’s emphasis on filth and destruction through the detailed precision of the poet’s language; however, the beauty of these things is realized as damnably dangerous—as the very snare that leads to the sinners’ destruction in the poem.  The poet’s sensual appeals to the readers are, in fact, acts of violence: the shining glory of Lucifer, the fair faces of the antediluvian races, the sway of the beardless angels’ hips as they enter Sodom, and the intricately detailed description of the Solomonic vessels at Belshazzar’s feast each appeal to the readers’ senses, and we, too, want to touch, to smell, to taste, to know, the delights that such forbidden fruits possess behind their shining exteriors.  We become sympathetically entangled with the most damnable figures in Biblical history, and we must repeatedly experience the horrific ugliness of God’s wrath, directed toward our newfound acquaintances.  The poet has seductively violated us by forcing us to confront our own filthy desires.

God’s own cleanness is not very pretty, and only by recognizing the offensiveness of the filth of his incarnation (born in the rottenness [rote] of a stable) can we begin to understand the complexities of filth and beauty.  Only by following the circumlocutionary logic of beautiful filth (or filthy beauty) can we begin to discover how to play safely with the sensually appealing things of the world, like a lover’s body or the Roman de la Rose.  Cleanness’s own form, the messiness of which continues to challenge scholars, resists the sterile, idolizing fetishizations found within its exempla and demands a closer, more fruitful analysis on its proper use.

Thursday, May 29, 2014

Æþelðryþe

Maybe the island is herself.

And the eels, everywhere.
Is it even an island?  Water?
Or maybe it’s not-water.
She longs for, she desires, the shore
Following the shipwreck.

God keeps wrecking the ship, though.
And he keeps asking her to get back on the ship.
And he keeps wrecking the ship.
Does he wreck the island, too?

The sea is too deep.
The stream is safe.
The stream is contained.
The stream has borders, and I can see the other side.
These marshes don’t even merit the name of a stream.

Can I trust you in the sea?
I don’t see the other side.
I’m scared of drowning, but here we are.

Jouissance.  Or maybe only partly.

Do you love me?
If you love me, you will keep my commandments:
Get back on the boat.
But the sea is so deep--

Isn’t it?  Don’t you know?

If we are the island, can we ever drown?


I’m scared

Friday, March 14, 2014

Seductive Seashores: St. Aethelthryth and the Transformative Promise of Seduction

Below is my abstract for the 2014 BABEL Working Group Conference "On the Beach: Precariousness, Risk, Forms of Life, Affinity, and Play at the Edge of the World":

            In the twelfth-century Liber Eliensis, Queen Aethelthryth’s flight away from her super-sexualized husband leads her to a marshy desert that is also a sea, a mountain/island/womb, an English countryside that looks uncannily like Egypt, Canaan, Nazareth, filtered through Bede’s eighth-century Historia ecclesiastica gentis Anglorum.  Standing within the protection of a cleft rock, Aethelthryth and her two maiden-companions watch as a raging sea encircles them, separating them from the maniacal lust of King Ecgfrith while transforming the desert of their hearts and wombs into flowing, life-giving fountains.  Aethelthryth flees from her husband, and she flees from earthly desire, not because she has no desire, but because she has too much.  Like the sea “pouring forth its water in many directions,” Aethelthryth’s desire is uncontainable, exceeding its boundaries, even (especially) as she “transferred all her yearnings towards the powers above.”
In her introduction to Towards a Theology of Eros, Virginia Burrus develops a metaphor introduced by Anders Nygren, by which agape compares to a well-defined stream and eros compares to an always-overflowing river.  According to Burrus (in opposition to Nygren), eros and agape must sometimes mix; the rivulet of agape must, at times, overflow its banks “in order to reopen its congested channels” (xv).  Aethelthryth’s agape surges like the sea of eros, rapt from its beach/marriage-bed, and transferred violently to a marshy wasteland, a damp landscape (not even meriting the name of a stream) in desperate need of the transformative waters of (erotic) passion.
Standing in the protective womb of the rock, surrounded by the waves of her own passion, Aethelthryth becomes a virgin mother who is also a figure of Moses, God’s vessel and mouthpiece, ready to lead God’s chosen people to the salvational shores of Paradise, an island very much like the cleft rock within the constant embrace of the passionate sea—the island of Ely
*       *       *
Are erotic discourses dangerous to the study of theology?  Should we assume that the author of the Liber Eliensis simply wrote in a traditional register, or hope that Aethelthryth’s desire for God is nothing more than a (safely) sublimated desire?  Or could we learn something by allowing ourselves to read the text for what it actually says, even allowing ourselves to be swept away by its overwhelming currents, where our embodied reading practices might feel the erotic presence of a just-beyond-reach, promissorily satiating Godhead?  Maybe we first need to surrender ourselves to a sea of passion in order to explore more fully the nuances of the Passion of Christ.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Sublime Bodies

Below is my abstract for the paper I am presenting in Reykjavik, Iceland, next July at the New Chaucer Society.  I have attached a digital composition inspired by my paper that I created for the freshman Seminar in Composition class that I am currently teaching.




Erotic Edification: Henry Suso’s Life of the Servant
and its Seduction of the Spirit

In The Life of the Servant, Henry Suso excites the senses of his readers through the enticing descriptions of his relationship with an androgynous Christ, and through these descriptions he proposes a model for the edification of the senses based on material seduction.  In resistance to the traditional dualistic approach to medieval asceticism, I follow scholars such as Caroline Walker Bynum and Robert Mills, whose scholarship argues for the mutual implications between the material world and late medieval spirituality.  Henry Suso reveals such a reliance on the material world, and although he proposes that the senses need to be disciplined, this edification does not serve to stifle the senses, but instead to heighten them.  The disciplining of the body allows one to make use of one’s corporeal experiences, one’s pleasure and pain, as a means of discovering God in creation.  The Servant’s beloved, depicted as both Christ and Lady Wisdom, seduces the Servant through his/her sensual appeal.  From his initial encounter with Lady Wisdom through Scripture to his sexualized union with Christ through corporeal self-punishment, the Servant’s senses play a significant role in his discovery of the blessed life.  Suso describes Eternal Wisdom as both a seductive courtly lady and a handsome young knight, he presents both Christ and the Servant as exposed bodies dripping with blood, and he excites the senses with vivid descriptions of celestial music, flowering gardens, and intoxicating smells.  Through such sensual imagery, Suso inspires a bodily response in the readers, a response deeply imbedded in erotic desire.  Suso’s text becomes just as seductive to the readers as are the eroticized bodies he describes, and its seductive capabilities parallel the Servant’s own conversion, occurring in response to a carnal reaction to erotic texts—the scriptural Books of Wisdom.  Suso reveals the usefulness of the material world and its sensual appeal in his choice of material descriptions that appeal to the senses (capable of enticing both the Servant and the readers); however, he further edifies his readers’ senses by discouraging the (logical?) development of this eroticized faith to the antinomian ends of the Free Spirit heresy.  By explicitly arguing that his text does not serve this end goal, he leaves the readers, whose senses are highly excited, looking for another outlet for this desire, and Suso presents God as this outlet.  Like the eroticized faith proposed and developed by such scholars as Ruth Mazo Karras, Karmen MacKendrick, and Nancy Partner, I argue that the edification that Suso offers to his readers relies on an intentional reorientation of material eroticism towards an intimate relationship with God.